Watertown, NY's Premier Pediatric Dental Office

Kids Dentist Watertown NY

Watertown Pediatric Dentistry opened its doors in August of 2011. Dr. Andrew was the first dentist to bring back a service that was missing for over 20 years to the North Country. We are the most established pediatric dental office in the area. Dr. Andrew Beuttenmuller, along with our dental staff, bring a whole new level of care to the field of pediatric dentistry.

As a pediatric dental practice, we are able to provide comprehensive primary preventive and therapeutic oral health care for infants and children through adolescence, including those with special health care needs. Dr. Beuttenmuller offers treatment with nitrous oxide and conscious sedation in office, and provides treatment at Samaritan Medical Center under general anesthesia.

When your child comes in for their appointment, they will feel relaxed and at home. We have a fun train theme throughout the office, and our waiting room is filled with toys and books for them to enjoy before their appointment. In each exam room we have monitors with a variety of movies that patients can watch while Dr. Beuttenmuller completes their dental work.

With a friendly staff, caring dentist, and inviting facility, you'll know your child is in good hands.


Meet Our Pediatric Dentists

Dr. Andrew Beuttenmuller - Watertown Pediatric Dentistry

Dr. Andrew Beuttenmuller


Dr. Andrew Beuttenmuller grew up in the Army. In 1992, he moved to Upstate New York where he graduated from South Jefferson High School in 1999. He completed his undergraduate education at Southern Virginia University receiving a Bachelors of Arts. He attended dental school at the State University of New York at Buffalo. Based on his high GPA and outstanding clinical achievement and involvement, he was asked to join the National Dental Honor Society.

In 2009, Dr. Beuttenmuller received his Doctor of Dental Surgery degree, graduating Magna Cum Laude. He then went on to complete an additional two years of training at Women's and Children Hospital in Buffalo, where he obtained a certificate in Pediatric Dentistry.

He completed certifications in 2012 when he became Board Certified and is now a diplomat of the American Academy of Pediatric Dentist. Dr. Beuttenmuller is an active member of the American Dental Association, the New York Dental Association, and the American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry.

When he is not working, Dr. Beuttenmuller keeps very busy with his four active boys. He enjoys spending time outdoors, skiing, camping, and playing bass guitar.

Dr. Andrew's associate, Dr. Amy Nagai, lives in Buffalo but comes every Thursday and Friday to work in Watertown.


Dr. Amy Nagai- Watertown Pediatric Dentistry

Dr. Amy Nagai


Dr. Amy Stone Nagai is a graduate of the University at Buffalo School of Dental Medicine where she completed both her Doctorate of Dental Surgery, as well as her specialty training in Pediatric Dentistry. Dr. Amy completed her undergraduate education at Hillsdale College in Michigan.

Dr. Amy was a chief resident during her residency with University Pediatric Dentistry. She is a guest lecturer at the School of Dental Medicine for Pediatric Dentistry, as well as a faculty member for the School of Dental Medicine's BOCA program (Buffalo Outreach and Community Assistance), which includes traveling locally, nationally, and internationally for dental mission trips for the underserved. Dr. Amy is also currently a clinical instructor for dental students and residents at Women and Children's Hospital in Buffalo. She serves as a clinical champion for a national collaborative focused on Early Childhood Caries and improved management of children's dental health.

Dr. Amy is a member of the American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry, The American Dental Association, The Eighth District Dental Society, The New York State Dental Association (where she serve as a representative to the New Dentist Committee), and the Western New York Association of Pediatric Dentists.




    Client Testimonials

  • "From the moment you walk into this office, you will not be disappointed! Between the awesome train set that circles the waiting and exam areas to the extremely pleasant staff, my child and I were beyond satisfied. Thank you for a great experience in a normally stressful situation!"

    Excellent Service and Atmosphere
    - Aiden L. -


  • "The dentist and all of the staff was wonderful about making us comfortable and making sure all our questions or concerns were answered. The office staff is very friendly and the office is clean and super kid friendly. Our daughter loved the waiting room and the toys and books there. Thank you for a great experience."

    5 Stars
    - Valerie Schultz -


  • "All of the staff were amazing. They all made my kids feel very comfortable. The waiting area was great but we didn't have to wait that long until they called my kids back! I would recommend this place to anyone who has kids!!!!"

    My Kids and I love this place!
    - Marcuz T. -


  • "As always your office exceeds our expectations and turns a bad situation into a tolerable one. Dr. Amy is amazing. All of the staff is so loving and patient. Just a wonderful place to take your little ones."

    4 year old visit
    - Cole G. -


  • Write a Review

Get Your Child on Track to a Healthy Smile!

Request an Appointment